Editorial standards
How Skillet & Hearth checks sources for cast-iron cookware, compares products, labels uncertainty and handles factual corrections.
How we check sources
For cast-iron cookware, we look for a manufacturer’s product page, manual or care instructions matched to the model being discussed. We use independent references where they help explain a method or corroborate a claim, and identify the sources readers can check in each guide.
Where a claim applies to a particular model, version or finish, we keep that condition attached to the claim. Unpublished or conflicting specifications are left unknown or explained in context.
How we compare products
We compare models on attributes that change a decision, such as rim diameter and cooking-surface diameter, total pan weight, cooking-surface finish and stated cooktop compatibility. A recommendation explains which reader it fits and the trade-off they would accept.
A desk-researched guide describes what the records support. Claims about personally handling, testing, measuring or using a product require documented work. We do not invent ratings or report a feature shared by one model as if it applies to an entire range.
How we write care and use instructions
Cast-iron care advice distinguishes bare or seasoned iron from enameled iron. Manufacturer-specific cleaning, oven-temperature and cooktop instructions take priority when a pan differs from the general advice.
Corrections and commercial links
To report a factual error, give us the guide URL, the item or instruction involved, and a source we can check. For product corrections, include the pan’s brand, exact model or size, and whether the surface is bare or enameled.
We review the evidence, update the affected guide when a correction is warranted, and use the article’s update date to indicate a material change. A qualifying retailer purchase can generate commission. Product placement still needs to be supported by the selection criteria described in the guide.